Is supervisor approval required for a show-up?

Is supervisor approval required for a show-up?

• A. Yes
• B. No
• C. Only for juvenile cases
• D. Depends on case

Answer: (A)

Show-ups are a highly time‑sensitive and potentially suggestive identification method, so they require careful oversight. Supervisory approval is needed to ensure the show-up is justified, properly timed, and conducted in a manner that minimizes bias and protects the rights of the witness and the suspect. The supervisor reviews whether a show-up is appropriate given the circumstances, and may require documentation, alignment with policy, and consideration of less suggestive alternatives (like a lineup) if feasible. This oversight helps preserve the integrity of the identification and reduce legal risk from misidentification. If a show-up is performed without approval, it can raise questions about procedure and admissibility in court, and can expose the department to discipline or legal challenges.

Show-ups are a highly time‑sensitive and potentially suggestive identification method, so they require careful oversight. Supervisory approval is needed to ensure the show-up is justified, properly timed, and conducted in a manner that minimizes bias and protects the rights of the witness and the suspect. The supervisor reviews whether a show-up is appropriate given the circumstances, and may require documentation, alignment with policy, and consideration of less suggestive alternatives (like a lineup) if feasible.

This oversight helps preserve the integrity of the identification and reduce legal risk from misidentification. If a show-up is performed without approval, it can raise questions about procedure and admissibility in court, and can expose the department to discipline or legal challenges.